Skip to main content
Jump to a category page

Some Amazon grocery shoppers ordered produce at a per-pound price and received one item for each “pound,” even when that item weighed far less. Emery | Reddy is investigating whether Amazon’s grocery pricing left customers paying more, or getting less, than the price they selected.

Emery | Reddy is investigating potential claims against Amazon, including Amazon Fresh and other Amazon-branded grocery sites. The investigation focuses on produce and grocery items listed with a per-pound or per-unit price, where the way Amazon charged or filled the order did not match that price. The firm is reviewing purchases dating back as early as January 2022.

How Per-Pound and Per-Item Pricing Is Supposed to Work

Grocery items are usually sold one of two ways. A per-item price is a flat price for each piece, such as one apple. A per-pound price is a rate based on weight, so the total depends on how much the order weighs.

A shopper who pays a per-pound price should receive that many pounds. A shopper who picks a per-item price should pay that price for each item. Problems start when a listing shows one method and the order is charged or filled using the other.

What Amazon Grocery Customers Are Reporting

Customer reviews on Amazon product pages for apples, pears and Roma tomatoes describe a similar pattern. The listing shows a per-pound price, but each item is sold as if it weighs exactly one pound. Many items weigh much less.

According to these reviews:

  • A shopper who ordered 8 pounds of apples received 8 apples, about half the weight ordered
  • A shopper who paid $1.00 per pound for Roma tomatoes received one tomato weighing about 0.20 pounds
  • Some listings show both a per-item price and a per-pound price, leaving shoppers unsure which one applies

When a one-pound price is charged for an item that weighs less, the shopper pays more per pound than the listed rate. Reviews describing this pattern date back to at least 2022.

Why Small Overcharges Add Up

A few cents or dollars on one order is easy to miss. Spread across many orders and many customers since 2022, small overcharges can add up to a large amount. Pricing practices like this may count as deceptive or unfair under state consumer protection laws.

Who May Be Affected

Customers may be affected if they bought groceries or produce through Amazon Fresh or another Amazon-branded grocery site in or after January 2022, and any of these happened:

  • The listing showed a per-pound or per-ounce price, but they received single items instead of the weight they ordered
  • They paid a one-pound price for each item, but the items weighed less than a pound
  • They were charged by weight for an item listed at a per-item price
  • They paid more, or received less, than the price they selected

Do You Have Legal Options?

Businesses must charge customers the price they advertise and deliver what customers pay for. If Amazon charged more than the listed price, or delivered less than shoppers paid for, affected customers may be able to recover the difference and other available relief under state consumer protection laws.

If you bought groceries from Amazon at a per-pound or per-item price and paid more, or got less, than you expected, call Emery | Reddy for a Free Case Review. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Emery | Reddy investigating?

Whether Amazon sold grocery and produce items in a way that did not match the listed price. This includes selling items listed per pound as if each item weighed one pound, and charging by weight for items listed per item.

Which Amazon services are included?

Amazon Fresh and other Amazon-branded sites that sell groceries. Most of the reported items are produce, such as apples, pears and tomatoes.

How far back does this go?

The investigation covers purchases going back as far as January 2022.

How can I tell if this happened to me?

  • Open your Amazon order history and find grocery orders
  • Check whether the item showed a per-pound or per-ounce price
  • Compare the pounds you ordered with the number of items you received
  • If you still have the items, weigh them
  • Check your card statement for the final amounts charged

What should I save?

  • Order confirmation emails and receipts
  • Screenshots of product pages showing the listed price, if you have them
  • Photos of what you received, including a scale reading if you have one
  • Card statements showing the charges

I already got a refund from Amazon. Should I still call?

Yes. A refund for one order may not cover every order affected over time. A Free Case Review can help sort out what may still be owed.

The overcharge was small. Does it still matter?

Yes. One small overcharge may not seem worth a call, but the same practice repeated across many orders and customers can add up. Each affected customer’s experience helps show the full picture.

Do I have a legal claim?

You may. Businesses must honor the prices they advertise and deliver what customers pay for. If Amazon charged you more, or sent you less, than the price you selected, call Emery | Reddy at 916.995.5968 or visit www.emeryreddy.com for a Free Case Review. No Fee Unless We Recover.

"Very friendly interview and intake process. I was informed thoroughly about the processes in obtaining a lawyer and was given ample time to make a decision on representation. I’m thankful for everyone’s help and looking forward to working with this Firm on my worker’s compensation claim."

- Darren A.

Receive a
FREE Case Review

Call Now